Thursday, August 16, 2018

Chao’s strategy to undermine multimodal transportation: A war of attrition


Since Elaine Chao took charge of the U.S. Department of Transportation, I've noticed a strong resemblance between the agency's Navy Yard headquarters and a Borg Cube (Photo by me)
Elaine Chao’s Department of Transportation is currently withholding $1.4 billion in congressionally- and presidentially-authorized funding for transit improvements. This continued withholding, which received substantial media attention this week following Transportation for America’s unveiling of its “stuck in the station” clock, threatens the viability of many badly needed infrastructure projects nationwide. Many commentators suspect that this is a deliberate effort by Chao, who worked for the Koch Brothers-funded Heritage Foundation prior to her appointment as DOT secretary, to derail the projects and continue to restrict peoples’ transportation options.

In contrast to some observers, I’m confident that Chao will release the funds soon. But this is not all good news, and it’s not even a new strategy for her – she’s made a habit of turning obligation of funds for projects that had seemed done deals, including the Maryland Purple Line and electrification of Caltrain, into months-long wars. Furthermore, she withheld 5 percent of Fiscal Year 2017 funds from every single large urban transit system in Maryland, Virginia, and DC, purportedly due to issues establishing a new safety oversight commission for a single rail system.

Chao may wish she could shift all of the money to roads, or just spend the taxpayer dollars on her own outings to popular attractions near her agency’s headquarters such as Nationals Park, Audi Field, and Bluejacket Brewing. But though she knows she could never get away with pocketing the cash, she still has great potential to harm multimodal transportation’s future, for two main reasons:
  • When the funds are finally released, transit advocates will celebrate pyrrhic victories after a long battle to make sure should-be no-brainer projects happen. Meanwhile, other proposals that deserve serious cost-benefit analysis will go forgotten.
  • Due to increasing prices for steel and labor, among other issues, project costs will rise due to the delays. Transit opponents will then cite these cost overruns as a result of government inefficiency in their efforts to justify cancellation of other would-be beneficial projects when, in fact, their own allies caused the overruns.    

To make sure Chao can’t cause long-term harm, we need to keep the pressure on

In contrast to other high-level Trump Administration officials, Chao, a longtime Washington insider and the wife of Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell, has largely managed to stay quiet and out of the spotlight. This allows her to pursue her goals with relative ease.

This may make her the cabinet member most likely to cause long-term harm to our country. Chao may have more cabinet experience than the likes of Ben Carson or Betsy DeVos, but she’s no less of a threat to the people. Her objective, as the GOP’s 2016 platform clearly describes, is to eliminate funding for all service transportation other than driving, taking away our freedom to choose how we get around. If she succeeds, we will all suffer.

We might not be able to change Chao, but we can make sure she’s not allowed to operate in the shadows any longer. Transportation for America’s efforts have given us a strong start to build on, but even once she releases the latest round of long-withheld funds we can’t let her off the hook.

From now on, I’ll be closely watching – and regularly reporting on – DOT’s management of multimodal transportation funds. Also, every time I happen to be near her agency’s headquarters, I’ll post to social media (as I’ve made a habit of recently) to make sure people remain aware of what’s going on in Chao’s Castle. I suggest you all do the same.  

If all goes well, maybe Trump will bid farewell to Chao with his iconic “you’re fired,” and finally commit to the multimodal infrastructure improvements he promised voters during his campaign. But I’m not holding my breath. 

No comments:

Post a Comment